A bench beneath a spreading live oak overlooks a sunlit green lawn in a palm-lined coastal Florida park.

Stuart Just Voted to Stop Asking Its Parks to Pay for Themselves

The parcel is 1.97 acres of undeveloped, overgrown land on U.S. 1, across from North River Shores Boulevard. It borders the 157-acre Haney Creek Preserve. For fifteen years it carried a different job, set by the voters of 2011: the city was to lease it for commercial use and put the income toward maintaining the preserve.

No lease ever happened. On November 3, Stuart voters approved rescinding that old requirement. They also approved a charter amendment that puts any future sale, or any lease longer than one year, of the ballfields at Guy Davis and Sailfish parks to a citywide vote. TCPalm reported on election night that voters "overwhelmingly approved" both measures.

Both measures concern land that has never covered its own costs. After the vote, that land stays public whether or not it earns anything, and the long-running budget question is settled.

The corner that was supposed to fund a preserve

According to the city's account, the City of Stuart and Martin County bought 51 acres of Haney Creek in 2011. That same year, city voters agreed to keep the commercially zoned parcel on U.S. 1 out of the preserve so it could produce lease income. The preserve opened to the public in 2016. It is named for Horace J. Haney, an early Stuart-area physician, and it protects part of the Haney Creek watershed, which drains into the South Fork of the St. Lucie River. Its habitats include coastal scrubland, pine flatwoods, wetlands and wet prairie.

Most visitors use the city's Haney Creek Park Nature Trails & Dog Park. The city's facility page lists a fenced dog park with separate sides for large and small breeds, a dog wash-down area, mapped nature trails where dogs must stay leashed, pavilions with picnic tables, and accessible restrooms.

The parcel by the road never generated income. Community Services Director Jim Chrulski told commissioners in August that the city had considered a restaurant, retail space, a hotel and affordable housing for the site, and "none of them ultimately moved forward," as Hometown News reported. In 2025 the commission approved a trailhead on the parcel. In 2026, after an unsolicited proposal from RaceTrac, it moved the planned trailhead to Baker Road, and commissioners started discussing whether commercial use was still the best fit for the corner.

The preserve has also managed without the money the parcel was meant to provide. At the August 17 hearing, Commissioner Eula Clarke said she had talked with Public Works Director Milton Leggett and learned the city had kept up the preserve over the years without any funds from that land. She recalled him saying "the money spent was minimal," according to Hometown News. The preserve also draws on a voter-approved half-cent sales tax for environmental improvements.

The 2011 revenue plan never produced any revenue, and it turned out the preserve did not need it.

Sailfish and Guy Davis bring back a dime or less per dollar of upkeep

The ballfield numbers make the same point more starkly. At a July hearing, Chrulski gave commissioners the 2025 usage figures, as reported by Hometown News.

Guy Davis Park Sailfish Park
User groups, 2025 24 25
Field reservations or uses, 2025 227 673
History noted by the city Site of an unsuccessful bid for state funding for a tournament complex Home to community baseball since the 1950s

The two parks together brought in about $31,000 in facility revenue in 2025. Commissioner Campbell Rich noted at the July hearing that the city's annual ballfield maintenance costs exceed $300,000. That works out to roughly a dime of revenue, or less, for every dollar of upkeep. Sailfish carried almost three times as many field uses as Guy Davis that year, and it is the park that set off the whole effort. In 2018, an unsolicited proposal to redevelop Sailfish Park drew public opposition, and the referendum grew out of that reaction.

The charter now makes the ballfields harder to sell. City Attorney Lee Baggett said the language mirrors protections the charter already gives certain waterfront properties: voter approval is required before the city can sell, convey or sign a long-term lease. The commission approved the draft language 4-0 on July 28 and passed the ordinance unanimously on second reading on August 17.

Why the 2011 logic lost

Former Mayor Christopher Collins first proposed changing the parcel's status in July 2025. He resigned on April 30, 2026, to run for the Martin County Commission, which left the city commission stuck on 2-2 votes on several issues until after the August primary. Commissioner Laura Giobbi and Mayor Sean Reed kept pushing the Haney Creek question forward.

At the August 17 hearing, Giobbi explained why she thought the 2011 reasoning no longer held. Hometown News recorded her comments:

"So much has changed since then. At that time, it seemed like that might be a good idea. What has happened is the amount of development."

The commission approved the ballot resolution 3-1 that night, with Rich voting no. Public speakers at the hearing were divided. One wanted to protect the native plants and animals on the parcel. Another argued that two acres along U.S. 1 could still bring in money for the preserve. Several others urged the commission to send the question to voters. On November 3, the voters settled it.

What still has to happen on U.S. 1

The vote removed the 2011 lease requirement, but the parcel is not part of the preserve yet. This is where each piece stands, based on statements from the city and its attorney:

  1. Land use and zoning. The parcel still carries a Commercial land use designation and Commercial Planned Unit Development zoning. Baggett told commissioners the city "will have to come back and go through the process of converting the land use."
  2. The interlocal agreement with Martin County. Under the original agreement, the city and county intended the parcel to produce maintenance revenue. Earlier in 2026, both governments approved resolutions amending it, each conditioned on voters approving the rescission.
  3. The Baker Road trailhead. This decision is already made. In 2026 the commission moved the planned trailhead off the U.S. 1 parcel to Baker Road.
  4. The ballfields going forward. Any future proposal to sell Guy Davis or Sailfish fields, or lease them for more than a year, now has to go to Stuart voters.

Together, these steps decide how the corner and the fields are handled the next time someone proposes to develop them.

Seven seats, and the deadline is Friday

The same thinking already has a dedicated funding source and is now getting a citizen committee. Stuart's Sustainable Acquisition of Land for Tomorrow initiative, known as SALT, is filling a seven-member citizen advisory committee. Members will evaluate land within city limits for preservation and public recreation, rank the options using the city's approved screening criteria, and send recommendations to the City Commission, which makes the final decision. The city's October 23 bulletin says SALT is funded by the half-cent sales surtax Martin County voters approved in 2024 for ten years to acquire and preserve environmentally significant land.

Applications close Friday, November 20, 2026, through the city's SALT application portal. Applicants must be over 18 and must have lived in the City of Stuart or unincorporated Martin County for at least one year. The city says a background in conservation, water quality, wetlands, wildlife habitat, recreation, stormwater, grant funding, property evaluation or real estate is helpful but not required. Questions go to City of Stuart Environmental Attorney Ruth Holmes at (772) 678-7905.

Downtown, Stuart Main Street lists Christmas on Main for November 27. Our September field notes from Stuart cover more of the historic core.

If you own near Haney Creek, Sailfish Park or Guy Davis Park and want to understand how these votes relate to your property, Scott Correale is glad to talk it through. Schedule a Private Consultation, or explore our Stuart neighborhood guide.

Work With Scott

With a deep understanding of the local market and an unrivaled global reach, Scott brings a wealth of knowledge and expertise to every transaction.

Follow Me on Instagram